Ink is a pigment or dye suspended in a liquid binder. The binder makes it flow, stick to the surface and dry without flaking. Everything else — colour, permanence, whether it bleeds through paper — follows from the choice of colourant and binder. Three traditional inks cover most needs, and all can be made with a pot, a fire and a little patience.
Three inks, three jobs
Carbon ink is soot held in gum arabic. It is opaque, dense, chemically stable and fairly water-resistant on sized paper once dry, though the gum binder can re-wet and smudge if it gets damp. It sits on the surface of the paper rather than soaking in, so it is excellent for drawing and for a bold black, but it can smudge while wet and may crack on a flexible surface.
Iron gall ink is made from tannin-rich oak galls and iron salts. It goes on pale and darkens as the iron oxidises, soaking into the paper and becoming permanent — sometimes too permanent, because the acidity slowly weakens the paper. It was the standard writing ink of Europe for centuries and is beautiful for documents, but it is not archival in the modern sense.
Berry, walnut and bark inks are dyes. They give lovely colours and are easy to make, but most fade in light within months. Use them for ephemeral notes, dyeing, stamps or decoration, not for records you need to keep.
Carbon ink: soot and gum
Collect lampblack by holding a clean metal plate or a ceramic saucer over a smoky flame — an oil lamp, a resinous pine torch or a small fire with green wood. The soot that collects is finely divided carbon. Let it cool, brush it into a jar, and keep it dry. Do not use soot from a chimney or from burning plastics, painted wood or treated timber; it contains tars and toxic compounds.
Make the binder first. Dissolve gum arabic in water at roughly 1 part gum : 2 parts water by weight. Stir occasionally for a few hours or leave it overnight; do not boil it. Strain through cloth. Then grind soot into a little of the gum solution on a stone or glass slab until it is smooth, and add more solution until the ink flows from a brush or pen without grit. A starting ratio is about 1 part soot : 2 parts gum solution by volume, but judge by eye: the ink should be thick enough to leave a solid black line and thin enough not to clog.
Add a few drops of clove oil or a little salt as a preservative, though neither is a guarantee against mould. Store in a stoppered glass bottle, labelled, in the dark. Shake before use. If the ink dries in the bottle, add a little water and grind again.
If gum arabic is not available, hide glue, egg white or cherry gum can act as a binder, but each changes the flow and permanence. Test small batches. Gum arabic is worth trading for; it is the best all-round binder for carbon ink.
Iron gall ink: galls and iron
Oak galls are the round growths on oak twigs caused by gall wasps. They are rich in tannic acid. Collect them when they are hard and brown, crush them, and steep them in soft water — roughly 20 g of crushed galls to 500 ml of water — for a day or more. Strain the brown liquor through cloth.
Add ferrous sulfate (green vitriol), about 10 g per 500 ml, and stir. The liquid darkens immediately as ferrous tannate forms. Add about 10 g of gum arabic to thicken and stabilise it. Let it stand for a day, strain again, and bottle. The ink will darken further as it oxidises on the page. A little clove oil slows mould.
The difficulty is the iron salt. Historically, green vitriol was made by roasting iron pyrites or by dissolving iron in sulfuric acid — neither is a primitive craft. A weaker substitute can be made by steeping rusty iron in vinegar for a week or two, producing iron acetate. It will darken gall liquor, but it is not the same chemistry and the result is less permanent. Label it honestly and test it before using it for anything important.
Iron gall ink is acidic. Over decades it can burn through paper, especially in humid conditions. Use it on good paper, keep documents dry, and do not use it for archival records if permanence matters more than tradition.
Berry, walnut and bark inks
For a simple dye ink, simmer a handful of elderberries, blackberries, walnut husks or oak bark in water for 30–60 minutes, crush and strain, then reduce the liquid gently. Add a little gum arabic for body and a pinch of salt or a few drops of vinegar as a mild preservative. Walnut hulls give a rich brown; elderberries give purple that fades to brown; onion skins give yellow-orange.
These inks are fugitive. Test them on a scrap of paper in a sunny window for a few weeks before using them on anything you care about. They are excellent for children’s work, stamps, dyeing and decoration, and they are a good way to learn about colour before investing in more permanent materials.
Binders, pens and surfaces
Gum arabic is the dried sap of acacia trees. It dissolves in water, dries clear and flexible, and keeps pigments suspended. Hide glue and egg white are alternatives but are less stable and more attractive to insects and mould. For a binder-free ink, use a fine pigment ground in water and apply it with a brush; it will rub off unless fixed with a size.
A quill is a flight feather cut at an angle, with the shaft split to make a nib. A reed pen is a hollow stem cut to a chisel tip; it gives a broader, more angular line. A brush gives the most control for ink wash. Make test strokes on scrap paper before writing; adjust the ink with water or gum until it flows without feathering.
Sizing the paper matters. Unsized handmade paper drinks ink and feathers badly; a light starch or gelatin size gives a crisp line. Test the ink on the actual paper you plan to use, not just on a smooth offcut.
Test and store
| Test | What to do | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Flow | Draw a line with a quill or brush | Grit or clogging means grind finer or add water |
| Feathering | Write on the intended paper | Spreading fibres need sizing or a thicker ink |
| Water resistance | Let dry, then dab with a wet finger | Carbon ink resists a brief dab; dye inks run; gum can re-wet |
| Light fastness | Tape a sample in a sunny window for 2–4 weeks | Fading tells you it is a dye, not a pigment |
| Mould | Leave a sample in a warm, damp place | Fuzz or smell means the preservative failed |
Store ink in dark glass with a tight stopper, labelled with the recipe and date. Keep it out of reach of children. If it grows a skin or smells sour, strain it and add a little preservative, or discard it. Never taste ink or use food containers for it.
Safety
Iron sulfate is harmful if swallowed and irritates skin and eyes. Wear gloves and goggles, label containers clearly, and keep them away from food and children. Soot and dust. Lampblack is fine and easily inhaled; grind it damp or wearing a respirator. Mould. Inks with natural gums and sugars grow mould; do not open a mouldy bottle near food. Poisons. Some traditional ink ingredients — lead, mercury, arsenic — are dangerous. Do not use them. Ink is not food. Keep all inks and dyes out of the kitchen.
Sources and further reading
- Wikipedia: Iron gall ink — chemistry, history and paper damage.
- Wikipedia: Ink — pigments, dyes and binders.
- Wikipedia: Oak apple — galls and their tannin content.
- Wikipedia: Gum arabic — properties and uses as a binder.